This is a
hypothetical interpersonal conflict situation which can be seen happening in
the workplace:
Steven and John were colleagues working under the same department in a business
company. Steven was a veteran who had been working in the company for more than
20 years, starting from a lowest position and working his way up steadily. On
the other hand, John was a fresh graduate with a degree in business management
and had just joined the company. He was employed and began his career at the
same position as Steven. Steven was unhappy when he knew that someone much
younger and inexperienced can be promoted so quickly, whereas for him, it took
years to achieve his current position.
Therefore, Steven was unwilling to guide and assist John when he needed
help. As a result, John had a bad relationship with Steven and refused to work
with him in a same project.
The main problem
of this conflict is due to the generation gap between Steven and John. Steven
may have a traditional mindset, he believe that one should work hard and experience
to deserve his current position. Therefore he would have felt envious and felt
that it was unfair as John did not work as hard as he did to earn the position.
John, on the other hand, may have felt that it was reasonable for him to earn
his new position as he is a degree holder.
If I were the
supervisor of Steven and John, I will speak to Steven personally and ask him
about his view on John. After which, I will explain about the areas where John
can contribute to the company. I will let Steven know that even though John is
of the same position as him, his experience and seniority is greatly recognized
by the company and John can never be comparable to him in that area. In order
to solve this conflict between Steven and John, there should be more
communication between the two parties so that they can understand each other
better.
What will you do
if you are the supervisor or colleague of Steven and John?
Hey Javis!
ReplyDeleteAs a supervisor I would adopt a similar strategy as yours by talking to Steven and showing him reason in John's value addition to that role. However, your suggestion is slightly one-sided as you suggested only to talk to Steven and then probe communication between Steven and John.
I feel that as a fresh graduate and newbie to the company, John has a responsibility as well to handle the X-Y generation gap. He could take initiative as well to ensure that he does not seem boastful or arrogant about his fast track to the position versus Steven's long years of hard work. Thus the supervisor also has to ensure that John is being considerate in this situation in order to resolve the conflict. Hence a supervisor should request both parties to be both accommodating as well as collaborative.
Cheers!
Hi Lakshmi!
DeleteWhat you say is very true indeed. If John tried to take initiative more and remain humble, I believe his relationship with Steven will definitely improve gradually. Btw I am looking forward for your peer teaching this Thursday. (:
Javis